3Commas alternative
3Commas is a polished trading-bot dashboard: you connect exchanges, then you set up dollar-cost averaging (DCA), grid, or SmartTrade. Their AI writes bot settings. Demo and backtest stay on 3Commas. Your API keys live in Sign Center. You whitelist 3Commas IPs.
Side by side
| 3Commas | CryptoBud |
|---|---|
| Paper trading first | |
| Partial | Yes Paper trading is the default. No API keys. |
| Preview before keys | |
| Partial | Yes See the current coins it would trade, before Sign in with Apple. |
| Keys on your box | |
| No Sign Center holds keys. Whitelist their IPs.5 | Yes Private cloud box. Keys stay on that machine. |
| Practice matches live | |
| Partial | Yes Same bot from paper trading to live. |
| Talk from Claude and others | |
| No | Yes MCP on your box. Same bot as the iPhone and web apps. |
- YesThe normal way the product works.
- PartialClose, but a different product. Demo, backtest, or a related tool.
- NoThe opposite, or they do not ship it at all.
How you get started
3Commas is a dashboard for people who will build the bot themselves. CryptoBud picks a style, shows a preview, and gives you a box.
Paper trading
3Commas Demo is a simulator. CryptoBud paper trading is the same bot you will take live.
- Demo “mimics real market conditions using live Binance Spot price data.” Orders execute inside 3Commas — they never reach the exchange.1
- No order-book simulation. Market orders fill as if liquidity is unlimited. Simulated fee is 0.1% per order.1
- “Demo trading is available on all paid plans.” Real trading is prioritized when the system is busy — demo can delay or interrupt.2
Where keys live
Both products keep coins on the exchange. 3Commas still holds the API key.
Does practice match live?
Talk from Claude and other AI agents
CryptoBud MCP is the same bot on your box. 3Commas does not ship MCP. They give you a REST API, Telegram commands, and an in-app chat that writes DCA bots.
- Official surface for apps and scripts is the 3Commas REST API: DCA bots, grid bots, SmartTrade, accounts. You create an API key and call HTTP. That is not MCP.6
- The official Telegram bot can /start_bot, /stop_bot, /my_bots, /my_stats. Commands from a phone chat, not from Grok, ChatGPT, or Claude.7
- AI Assistant (Gemini) lives in the 3Commas UI. It creates and backtests DCA bots. It cannot manage existing bots, and it does not create Grid or SmartTrade.8
- A community GitHub project wraps the REST API as MCP. It is not a 3Commas product. Default is read-only. You paste your 3Commas API key into the client.10
What it costs
3Commas sells plan tiers. Live bots start on a paid plan. CryptoBud is a flat subscription for the private box.
- Starter is $20/month, Pro $50/month, Expert $140/month. A free account exists — it does not run live bots.11,12
- Demo trading is on paid plans. When the system is busy, real trading is prioritized and demo can delay or interrupt.2
- CryptoBud is $12.99/week ($44.99/month, $449.99/year) at cryptobud.app/checkout. Flat. No fee on your trades, no cut of profits.
Who should pick which
How we compare
We read their homepages, FAQs, help centers, App Store listings, and spend a fair amount of time using the products. These are product facts you can check yourself. We skip who will make you more money. Last check: August 25, 2026.
What we skip3
- Advertised returns. Stoic publishes past strategy results. We did not audit those numbers. We will not argue about yearly return percentages.
- How many exchanges. 3Commas, Cryptohopper, and Bitsgap sell a dashboard across many exchanges. CryptoBud is a Binance Spot trading bot. Listing more venues is their product.
- Funds that hold your coins. If you send them coins and wait, that is a different product. We do not write that comparison.
Sources12
Every competitor claim on this page points here. We quote their help centers, FAQs, and App Store listings — not something we made up.
- 13Commas Help — Demo account(opens in a new tab)
- 23Commas Help — Enable Demo account(opens in a new tab)
- 33Commas — homepage(opens in a new tab)
- 43Commas — Backtesting(opens in a new tab)
- 53Commas — Security(opens in a new tab)
- 63Commas — API(opens in a new tab)
- 73Commas Help — Telegram bot commands(opens in a new tab)
- 83Commas Help — AI Assistant(opens in a new tab)
- 93Commas — App Store(opens in a new tab)
- 10GitHub — community 3Commas MCP(opens in a new tab)
- 113Commas — Pricing(opens in a new tab)
- 123Commas Help — Available subscription plans(opens in a new tab)
Paper trading first — live when you say so
Common questions
Does 3Commas store my API keys?
Yes. Sign Center holds them and signs trades. You whitelist official 3Commas IPs on the exchange. Bud keeps keys on your private cloud box and emails you that IP for the Binance allowlist.
Is 3Commas paper trading the same as live?
No. Their help center says demo orders never hit the exchange, fills are perfect, and there is no order book. Demo is also a paid-plan feature, and live traffic gets priority when the system is busy.
Is CryptoBud a 3Commas alternative?
Yes if you do not want to build DCA and grid bots on a shared dashboard. No if you need one screen across many exchanges — 3Commas is that product. CryptoBud is a Binance Spot trading bot on a box that is yours.
How much does 3Commas cost compared to CryptoBud?
Live bots start at Starter, $20/month. Pro is $50/month, Expert $140/month. The free account does not trade live. CryptoBud is $12.99/week ($44.99/month, $449.99/year) at cryptobud.app/checkout. Flat.
Does 3Commas have MCP for Cursor or Claude?
3Commas does not ship MCP. Official extras are a REST API, Telegram bot commands, and an in-app AI Assistant that writes DCA bots. A community GitHub wrapper exists. CryptoBud MCP runs on your private box. Same bot as the iPhone and web apps.
